First I’ve got to thank Scott Lowe for his blog post “Blogging for the right reasons” for the motivation to get this one wrapped up. It’s been sitting in my drafts for a while now, long enough that vEXPERT2010 was more than one other thing before. This is just my PoV, let me know what you think!
Back in 2004, I thought I knew enough to be dangerous with IT. Whether it was RedHat, Mandrake (hey don’t judge), Solaris, that odd little GSX box in the corner, or the suite of DoD software that I was supporting, I was pretty sure I knew what I was doing. I knew these technologies pretty well. Or so I thought. I was already blogging, I had already moved my awesome geocities page to a early blogging platform, and was migrating again to some early version of wordpress, running on some shiny new desktop in my basement that was also my ipchains firewall. I was ubercool.
After going to my first CIALUG meeting what I realized though was that I was missing the most important part of linux and opensource in general. Open collaboration. When I went home, something had changed. Sure, I’d learned something, sure I’d talked about my awesome new mythtv box I was working on, but something different had happened. There had been a fundamental shift in the importance in my mind of community.
For those of us active in any community, this cohesion can be a profound, life changing thing. We get angry when people/companies threaten out culture, and the linux community, really, as a collective, isn’t the most socially elegant group out there.
When my work started focusing more and more around vmware, the blogging community that had sprouted up around vmware was something I could relate too. There was that sense of community, that sense of passion that Scott writes about, and I was drawn to it. It’s great being a part of a community, where you can contribute what you know, and continue to learn more yourself.
Along with a host of great blogs the VMUGs were (and still are) a great way for new (and existing) members of the community to reconnect, share information, and stay engaged. The only thing that is glaringly different was and is that the VMUGs are run by vmware corp. That’s just the way that it is, I’m not saying it’s bad or good, I’m just saying; that’s the way it is.
The elephant in the room with the vmware community as a whole is that we’re a community of use. Although some of us exist inside the corp firewall of vmware or EMC proper, we don’t, as a community, develop the software. We use it. Nothing wrong with that, but there is a fundamental difference in the community surrounding vmware and the community surrounding linux distro X or software package X. Even the wonderful and completely awesome work that is being done /w powershell is completely dependent on the existence of a financially viable company. The code doesn’t stand separate. (Some would point out here that “linux” in general isn’t really developed by the “community” at this point either. Best left for a separate conversation I suppose)
This difference impacts the way we write, and what we write about. We’re “users” and we await the latest feature, ready for that surprise shock and awe that accompanies it. We like to be “in the know”, aware of the next feature that is going to come out before anyone else. But when we do know. WE SHARE. Sharing that information, the best configurations, a PS script, the awesomeness that is the community powerpack, the mini monitor by Nick Weaver, these are the things that make our community work. The forums are great, and the amount of data in there is insane. Someone once said that the average time to get an answer to a well described problem on the vmware forums was under 10 minutes. That’s free support for vmware, delivered in the best way possible. From your peers. From another person who has been there before.
Are you still with me? This brings me to the topic of Scott’s post.
While I blog, In my head, I instantly translated this to, “participating in the community for the right reasons.” Why? He mentions twitter, and really, there are more places to get recognized by “Company X” than just via a blog and twitter. And most people I know don’t just blog about tech stuff, heck, I don’t blog just about vmware or linux. I blog about, well, just look up and to your right.
So how could someone participate for the wrong reasons? I’m not an active participant in the forums, but there is REAL value in doing that. I’m not the most regular attendee to our VMUGS, (I don’t like driving the distance of Paris to Brussels for a VMUG………shocked, I’m sure) but there is REAL value in participating in the VMUGs. I’m not the most regular blogger, but again, to those that do, however often, there is REAL value in doing that.
That value, that sharing of knowledge, is important to those that also involved, or more importantly, to those that are just now trying to figure out how to get involved.
I’ll wrap this up for the 2 of you that made it this far. Participate in the vmware community however you can best contribute. We don’t care what your reasons are, you may be an employee just doing your job, you may be a ROCKSTAR vmware admin with time to assist, you may be a published technical author, a vmware instructor, shoot, you may be all of the above, just get, and stay, involved. We’ll all be better because of it.
And if you’re blogging for the wrong reasons, well, keep blogging. you may surprise yourself down the road.
In my head, if we start to judge the why people are writing, the potential creeps in where we’re setting an elitist bar that tries to separate out an “us” from “them”. I’ve never seen that play out well in any community that I’ve been a part of. That growing number of blogs you see that concerns you? Chances are they are people that look up to you, so get personal. If you have a concern, ask them.
And to the email I got from the person asking if they may be looked at differently for starting a blog after Scott’s post, the answer is NO. A resounding NO. DO IT. Honestly, we don’t care why you’re doing it, just get involved.
by google.com/profiles/10…
10 Jun 2010 at 09:47
Theron,
I enjoyed reading this post and I agree with much of what you have to say. The one point I disagree with is this comment: “The only thing that is glaringly different was and is that the VMUGs are run by vmware corp”. I think this comment without further explanation is a bit misleading.
Note: It may not come as a surprise that I am a local VMUG leader. I run the Wisconsin VMUG.
The VMUG program as a whole is run by VMware but the local VMUGs are not “run” by VMware. The local VMUGs are run by the local VMUG leaders or leadership groups. They are supported on the backend by VMware but the meetings themselves are run locally. The local VMUG leader has the freedom to set the schedule and agenda for the meetings. After almost 3 years I have not cleared an agenda with VMware prior to a meeting or had someone at VMware ask me to change a meeting agenda.
While the content is generally about a VMware product/technology or a VMware related vendor product, keep in mind that VMUG stands for VMWARE User Group.
Thanks for the great post and for being a great contributor to the VMware (& IT) community.
Rod
vExpert 2009-10
by theron
10 Jun 2010 at 10:08
@ Rod.
Good points! I should have flushed out that thought. The point was by it’s the very nature of “VMUG stands for VMWARE User Group” it is tied into vmware as part of that community of use, but, it is controlled.
Have you tried to stand up your own VMUG?
The content and running is community driven, but the governance is certainly in the hands of vmware corp. This IS different from other User Groups, (such as LUGs) where the governance is 100% in the hands of it’s members. So even in it’s VMUGs, we are users of the framework that vmware provides. Gotta reiterate here, that’s not necessarily a bad thing, it’s just the way it is
Thanks!
-theron
by google.com/profiles/10…
10 Jun 2010 at 11:17
I have not looked into a seperate VMUG. I do know some others people that have talked about a VUG (Virtualization Users Group).
In a big picture perspective of User Groups, the VMUG program is still a relatively new and evolving organization. That being said, in our industry things change fast and some things never get the opportunity to be around a long time.
The VMUG program has had massive growth the last few years (along with VMware). Have faith in the VMUG program and a little more patience as it continues to grow and evolve.
Rod
by theron
10 Jun 2010 at 13:18
patience? I’ve got it in droves
I’m still a huge fan of the VMUGs, they’re EXTREEEMELY useful for folks getting together to learn about vmware, and the supporting ecosystem. Very cool stuff. I think the VMUGs are a very narrow point in the post though. Biggest takeaway should be GET INVOLVED! DO SOMETHING! I think it’s important for new (and some of the folks that have been a round for a while) to realize and remember.
-Theron